Biological Reviews

Reproductive seasonality offsets the energetic costs of reproduction by synchronizing births with peak resources and is traditionally expected to increase with latitude and environmental seasonality. However, life-history and behavioural strategies may also buffer energetic shortages and reduce dependency on environmental cycles. Here, we propose and test an integrative framework integrating climatic, life-history and behavioural factors using high-resolution measures of reproductive seasonality for 132 wild primate populations from 94 species. As expected, reproductive seasonality declines at lower latitudes, in less seasonal and in less predictable environments, even after controlling for productivity. It also decreases in species that spread reproductive costs by extending developmental periods, or when a higher infant mortality urges females to resume fertility shortly after loss. Unexpectedly, reproductive seasonality increases with environmental productivity and is not reduced by cognitive (foraging innovations), social (allomaternal care), or ecological (dietary breadth) buffering. Broader diets even enhance seasonality. These findings suggest that reproductive seasonality emerges from opportunity more than from constraints in productive environments, where females exploit abundant resources to accelerate their reproductive pace. Together, our results shed light on the diverse selective pressures shaping primate reproductive seasonality, including climate, life-history pace, and infanticide risk, and help to explain why humans reproduce year-round.

Innovation of the avian beak has facilitated a grand radiation of >11,000 species, with vast morphological disparity suggesting limited developmental constraints on beak diversification. We assess four macroevolutionary currencies - integration, disparity, phenotypic evolutionary rates, and ecological specialization - using 3D beak landmarks for 8,627 species mapped to a complete avian supertree with a resolved genomic backbone. We introduce a Gini coefficient-based metric of ecological specialization, measuring evolutionary time spent across trophic niches. Phylogenetic regressions show that lineages with faster phenotypic rates exhibit stronger beak integration (landmark covariation) and more generalised diets, while beak disparity declines with greater trophic specialization. These results suggest that integration facilitates, rather than constrains, phenotypic evolution, by channeling variation along lines of least resistance. Future work should explore modular structure of the bird beak, which arises from multiple genetic and developmental factors.

Acoustic interference is a critical factor driving the evolution of communication systems. In mixed-species aggregations, competition for acoustic space is expected to drive signal differentiation among heterospecifics. The acoustic space partitioning hypothesis proposes that species differentiate their signals to reduce overlap and thereby acoustic interference. Despite ongoing debates in niche theory, studies in animal communication have remained disconnected from these conversations, and no critical evaluation of this hypothesis has been conducted. We performed a systematic review to assess empirical support for acoustic space partitioning and evaluate the conceptual and methodological approaches used to test it. We found that two-thirds of studies conclude that the acoustic space is partitioned, albeit with a strong taxonomic bias toward anurans. However, studies rarely account for key assumptions of the hypothesis, including cosignaling, limited acoustic space, and masking of the signal at the receiver. Without explicit evidence of conditions for acoustic interference, signal differentiation alone is insufficient to infer competition as the main mechanism driving partitioning, since this outcome may also arise from alternative processes. By integrating coexistence theory and sensory ecology, we provide a framework to reconcile signal-structure differentiation with receiver perception, thereby improving our understanding of how communication systems evolve in mixed-species aggregations.

Anseriformes (waterfowl) and Galliformes (landfowl) are among the worlds most recognisable groups of birds, together comprising the clade Galloanserae. Despite their close evolutionary relationship, the skulls of adult anseriforms and galliforms exhibit strikingly distinct morphologies, the developmental basis and evolutionary history of which is poorly understood. To illuminate the developmental and evolutionary underpinnings of cranial disparity between and within these major extant bird clades, we quantitatively investigated ontogenetic changes in cranial morphology across galloanseran phylogenetic diversity, focusing on the previously unexplored post-hatching interval during which adult morphology takes shape. Our results reveal the combined effects of multiple heterochronic shifts early in galloanseran evolutionary history including anseriform hypermorphosis, along with influential non-heterochronic changes leading to substantially more disparate ontogenetic trajectories--and greater cranial variability--in anseriforms than galliforms. Key galloanseran fossils help clarify the polarity of evolutionary shifts in cranial development through galloanseran phylogenetic history and demonstrate that extant galliform cranial morphology is more constrained and retains a more plesiomorphic morphology than that of anseriforms. Our work helps illuminate the developmental basis of the iconic differences in cranial form between waterfowl and landfowl and illustrates the importance of broad phylogenetic and ontogenetic sampling for clarifying patterns of post-hatching developmental divergence among major vertebrate clades.

Limb loss in vertebrate animals is surprisingly common despite imposing strong functional constraints. These pressures funnel species towards regions of limited ecological and phenotypic space. To date, snakes have been considered unique in having escaped this pattern. Using a new species-level phylogeny and comparative morphological and dietary datasets, we show that pygopods, a group of limbless Australo-Papuan geckos, have undergone a similar evolutionary trajectory to snakes. Our analyses provide evidence of exceptional morphological and diet evolution. This is exemplified by strong niche partitioning among genera through dietary specialization and greater than expected dietary disparity. Diversification in pygopods has also been driven by extreme phenotypic evolution, with pygopods encompassing much of the morphological space covered by all other limb-reduced lizards. Interestingly, the diversification of pygopods has resulted in only a modest number of species, emphasizing the decoupling of diversity and richness possible in adaptive radiations.

Accelerated warming at high elevations is having a disproportionate impact on alpine species. While assessments of climate vulnerability require quantifying the ecological and evolutionary components of adaptive capacity, such assessments are rare, especially in alpine systems. We leverage recent advances in population and landscape genomics to assess how variation in spatial heterogeneity and population connectivity across alpine systems influences adaptive capacity, using the North American Rosy-Finch species complex as a model system. In doing so, we clarify taxonomic relationships across the complex and identify one new ESU, the Sierra Nevada Rosy-Finch, based on its combined ecological and evolutionary distinctiveness. We then illustrate how combining genomic analyses with ecological data can improve estimates of adaptive capacity, sensitivity, and exposure and ultimately clarify climate vulnerability. Overall, our integrative analyses revealed that more isolated lineages, such as the Sierra Nevada Rosy-Finch, have lower adaptive capacity and face disproportionately high risks from climate change. This work highlights how conservation strategies that account for the multidimensional aspects of adaptive capacity can improve estimates of climate vulnerability.

Sexual selection is a major evolutionary force, yet its demographic consequences remain unclear. While experimental studies often report positive effects of sexual selection on traits linked to population performance, comparative studies often find null or negative associations with population persistence. One explanation for this discrepancy is that the demographic consequences of sexual selection depend on ecological context, particularly variation in mortality and fecundity. Here, we used six decades of abundance data and test whether sexual selection predicts population trends across 738 bird species from Europe and North America. We quantify sexual selection using complementary proxies capturing different components of sexual selection: mating system, sexual dichromatism, sexual size dimorphism and relative testes mass. We further assess whether the effect of sexual selection in population trends is mediated by mortality and fecundity. Across all proxies, we found no evidence that sexual selection is associated with population trends. This result is consistent across continents and robust to variation in mortality and fecundity. Our findings suggest that, despite its central role in shaping phenotypic evolution, sexual selection does not translate into consistent effects on long-term population trends at macroecological scales. More broadly, these results highlight a potential disconnect between evolutionary processes and population dynamics.

All organisms interact with other organisms, directly, and indirectly through different ecological relationships involving multiple types of interactions. Yet at broad continental scales, we lack comprehensive information on biotic interactions, which has hindered our ability to answer macroecological and eco-evolutionary questions across scales and to fully quantify the diversity of biotic interactions as an important dimension of biodiversity. Here, we help fill these gaps with an open and comprehensive dataset and data workflow of 25,907 pairwise, directional interspecific interactions among birds spanning a continental scale. All data are empirically documented and comprise bird-bird interactions across both breeding and non-breeding ranges of 731 focal avian taxa, covering all birds in the focal region of Canada and the continental United States, including Alaska. These data also include 1,258 additional avian taxa interacting with the focal taxa outside the focal region, resulting in 1,989 avian taxa altogether. The continental scale and breadth of interspecific interactions within these data fill fundamental knowledge gaps and enable scientists and practitioners to address a myriad of questions at broader scales than were previously possible.

Factors varying along elevational gradients impose strong aerodynamic and physiological constraints on powered flight, yet the internal anatomical correlates of flight performance in animals under such conditions remain poorly understood. In hummingbirds, sustained hovering requires extreme muscular power output, making the pectoralis muscle a key interface between environmental constraint and performance. We tested whether elevation is associated with variation in pectoralis microanatomy across three hummingbird assemblages spanning a [~]1500 m gradient in the Colombian Andes. Using tissue morphometry of trichrome-stained transverse sections of the pectoralis, we measured interstitial collagen fraction as a proxy for extracellular matrix investment and quantified fiber cross-sectional area, packing density, and size heterogeneity. Collagen investment varied across elevational bands, peaking at mid elevation ([~]1750 m) and declining toward high elevation ([~]2600 m). In contrast, muscle fibers were smaller and more densely packed at higher elevations. Variation among species was small relative to differences among elevational assemblages. Formal model comparisons provided limited support for non-linear responses to elevation, indicating that patterns across traits are better explained by interacting constraints than by a single monotonic response to factors varying along elevational gradients. These results show that hummingbird flight muscle microanatomy varies with elevation in a trait-specific manner, with the strongest evidence in fiber geometry. More broadly, our findings highlight that multiple components of muscle microarchitecture, including the extracellular matrix, vary in a context-dependent manner across elevational gradients in an extreme volant system.

Land-bridge islands are former mainland areas isolated by post-glacial sea-level rise (<15,000 years) and the most common island type. Because of their recurrent connectivity with continents, it is unclear whether species on land-bridge islands can undergo evolutionary changes associated with the more isolated oceanic islands ( island syndrome). Here, we test the hypothesis that the selective environment on land-bridge islands exerts predictable and consistent evolutionary shifts in morphological traits of songbirds. We apply Bayesian hierarchical models to a morphological dataset of 6,917 individuals comprising 185 species of songbirds from four land-bridge islands (Bioko, Sri Lanka, Taiwan and Trinidad) and adjacent continents. Across all 185 species, we find that occurrence on a land-bridge island has clear directional effects on five morphological traits related to beak, wing, and tarsus, as well as a general increase in body size. At the species level, 57 out of 90 tested species exhibit significant morphological divergence between land-bridge island and mainland, yet for only 20 of these are the land-bridge island populations recognised as distinct endemic subspecies. Our results show that occurrence on land-bridge islands has a detectable effect on passerine morphology consistent with the island syndrome, and suggest these islands harbour previously unrecognized unique biodiversity.

ContextAnimals balance resource acquisition with risk mitigation. These trade-offs are rarely uniform, being mediated by spatial scale, demographic traits, and environmental constraints. Understanding these divergent spatial behaviors is critical for management across human-dominated landscapes. ObjectivesWe investigated how sexual dimorphism and ontogeny interact with landscape structure to influence scale-dependent resource selection. Specifically, we sought to determine how these demographic factors mediate spatial trade-offs between optimal foraging habitats, top-down intraguild predation risk, and bottom-up severe winter weather. MethodsWe examined the spatial ecology of a solitary carnivore, the bobcat (Lynx rufus), across a heterogeneous, human-modified landscape in northern Minnesota, USA. Using spatial data derived from harvested adult and juvenile individuals, we evaluated multi-scale selection relative to land cover, structural ecotones, intraguild predator activity, and winter severity. ResultsHabitat selection was scale-dependent and partitioned demographically. Whereas bobcats universally selected for ecotones and avoided homogeneous open habitats at fine scales, responses to other features diverged by sex and age. Females actively avoided areas with high coyote activity and freezing temperatures; males exhibited high risk tolerance, apparently indifferent to coyote activity and tolerant of freezing temperatures. We identified a distinct ontogenetic spatial shift among females. Subordinate juveniles were competitively excluded from optimal natural ecotones, forcing them into riskier, anthropogenic agricultural edges. In contrast, adult females optimized foraging opportunities by selecting productive ecotones at the intersection of woody vegetation and semi-natural grasslands. ConclusionsOur findings demonstrate that habitat selection is not a static species-level trait, but instead a dynamic process resulting from the interaction between ontogeny, sex, and landscape heterogeneity. The reliance of vulnerable demographic groups on marginal or anthropogenic habitats highlights how human land-use changes can inadvertently produce ecological winners and losers within the same species. Consequently, landscape management and conservation planning for solitary carnivores must shift from broad, population-wide habitat prescriptions to strategies that explicitly accommodate the divergent spatial requirements of specific demographic cohorts.

Parasites can alter host populations in fundamentally different ways depending on whether exposure results in infection. Yet, most epidemiological and evolutionary inference focuses on established infections, leaving the fitness consequences of parasite exposure comparatively understudied. This gap is consequential because hosts are frequently exposed to diverse parasite genotypes, and these encounters can impose substantial fitness costs even when infection does not occur. Theory predicts that hosts may mitigate these costs when interacting with commonly encountered parasite genotypes, such that exposure to sympatric parasites incurs lower fitness consequences than exposure to novel, allopatric parasites. Here, we examine the fitness consequences of exposure and infection in the first intermediate host of the trophically transmitted tapeworm Schistocephalus solidus, a cyclopoid copepod that serves as the first host in a three-host life cycle. Using sympatric (Vancouver Island, Canada) and allopatric (Norway) host-parasite combinations, we found a striking reciprocal asymmetry. Sympatric parasites were significantly more infective, yet exposure to sympatric parasites imposed weaker fitness costs when infection did not establish. In contrast, allopatric parasites were less infective, but exposed females produced fewer eggs and had lower hatching success than both controls and females exposed to sympatric parasites, indicating substantial genotype-dependent costs of exposure. Moreover, we found that infection was highly virulent across all genotypes: a single parasite caused near-complete reproductive suppression and reduced host survival across all host-parasite pairings, confirming S. solidus as a castrating parasite in copepods. Together, these results demonstrate that exposure, not just infection, acts as a critical ecological filter with potentially large and underappreciated consequences for host population dynamics and parasite transmission.

Observed group sizes rarely match the size that would maximize what each member gets from belonging. We propose a two-part theory in which group size is regulated by two related conflicts: insider-outsider conflict over admission, and within-group conflict as crowding, competition, and social tensions intensify with size. Three strategies are available: admission, exclusion, and fission. The first part shows that even when exclusion is unavailable, fission dynamics alone drive group size away from the optimum in both directions, with the pattern set by how prospective joiners encounter groups and by the geometry of fission. When joiners compare groups across a shared landscape and fission is asymmetric, the standing distribution is bimodal: supra-optimal large groups coexisting with a sub-optimal mode of small groups, the pattern characteristic of fission-fusion societies. The second part promotes exclusion and fission to active decisions: incumbents weigh the per-capita cost of accommodating entry ({beta}) against the costs of coordinated exclusion (c +{gamma} N*) and fissioning (F). A single inequality, {beta} > c +{gamma} N*, partitions populations into two regimes: where it holds, exclusion is viable and groups lock at the optimum size; where it fails, groups grow past the optimum and cycle through recurrent fission. Modal group size, fission frequency, and exclusion behavior together identify which regime governs a population -- a set of predictions applicable across fishes, social insects, birds, and mammals including primates and human foragers.

Why do some lineages diversify while others do not? This remains a central question in evolutionary ecology. A long-standing assumption, dating to Darwin and embedded in the Unified Neutral Theory of Biodiversity, holds that abundant species should speciate at higher rates. Conversely, theoretical and empirical work highlights the possibility that rare and dispersal-limited clades might be more prone to speciation. Using a birth-death-immigration model with protracted speciation in a multi-population landscape connected by limited dispersal, we show that abundance has a hump-shaped effect on probability of speciation. Our model reveals that intermediate abundance maximizes speciation probability because larger populations disperse more, swamping regional differentiation and inhibiting speciation completion, while smaller populations lack the persistence and incipient speciation needed to diversify. We find empirical support for this prediction with an analysis of data from arthropods endemic to Hawaii, where genus-level species richness shows a significant hump-shaped relationship with mean genus abundance. These findings provide a mechanistic explanation for a nuanced relationship between abundance and diversification.

Small mammals, particularly rodents and shrews, act as primary reservoirs for Arenaviruses and Hantaviruses, zoonotic pathogens causing substantial global morbidity. However, our understanding of reservoir ecology is obscured by biased surveillance efforts, where sampling preferentially targets synanthropic species and high-income regions. It remains unclear whether observed patterns of reservoir competence, such as the association with synanthropy, are biological realities or artefacts of surveillance bias. We conducted a systematic review and data synthesis of global surveillance efforts (1960-2023), creating a harmonised database of over 590,000 recorded small mammals contributing 716,000 assay results. We then integrated this with macroecological trait data and phylogenetics to model reservoir probability using Bayesian phylogenetic dyadic generalised linear mixed models. We identified substantial taxonomic and geographic biases; surveillance is heavily skewed towards the Palearctic and widespread, large-bodied species, while 46% of host genera remain entirely unsampled. Geographically, surveillance intensity correlates strongly with accessibility and night-light intensity rather than host biodiversity. After statistically correcting for historical sampling volume, we demonstrate that reservoir status is a predictable biological trait. A fast pace of life (e.g., early maturity, large litters) is associated with an increased probability of reservoir status, independent of sampling effort. Synanthropy also remains a strong, independent predictor, indicating that commensal species act as genuine biological amplifiers in modified landscapes. Evolutionary analyses reveal a mosaic of broad lineage-level co-divergence punctuated by frequent, reactive host-switching. By projecting these models globally, we demonstrate that anthropogenic disturbance acts as an ecological filter, fundamentally challenging the assumption that pristine tropical ecosystems represent the highest intrinsic hazard for viral emergence.

AimBiodiversity-rich regions often lack the scientific infrastructure needed to document and curate their own biodiversity, creating inequalities in access to taxonomic reference material. We investigated how biological, institutional, and geopolitical factors shape the retention, extraction, and appropriation of reptile holotypes, the name-bearing specimens upon which species descriptions are based. LocationGlobal. TaxonReptiles. MethodsWe compiled a historical dataset of reptile holotype origins and destinations spanning 1758-2024 to reconstruct long-term patterns of retention and international specimen flows. We then quantified species-level holotype retention, holotype flows between country pairs, and country-level patterns of retention, appropriation, and network centrality for the period 1990-2024, and used generalised linear mixed models to assess the biological, institutional, and geopolitical determinants of these contemporary circulation processes. ResultsAlthough nearly 90% of reptile species described originated in the Global South, less than a quarter of their holotypes remain housed there. Historically, exported holotypes consistently outnumbered retained holotypes on a decadal basis until the early twenty-first century. Retention was promoted by local scientific capacity, institutional infrastructure, collector involvement in species descriptions, and environmental governance. In contrast, extraction was concentrated in highly endemic regions with limited scientific infrastructure and was associated with taxonomic revisions, socioeconomic interest, and disparities in political stability and colonial history. Appropriation of foreign holotypes was greatest in countries with high research investment, strong environmental governance, and historical geopolitical influence. Main conclusionsGlobal patterns of holotype circulation reflect a persistent geography of scientific inequality. The distribution of taxonomic reference material emerges from the interaction of retention, extraction, and appropriation processes, linking local biodiversity discovery to uneven global scientific capacity. Reducing these inequalities will require investments in taxonomic expertise, institutional infrastructure, and governance frameworks that promote more equitable stewardship of biodiversity knowledge and its material foundations.

Northern gannets (Morus bassanus) have been regarded as a seabird success story, due to population increases throughout the 20th and 21st century contrasting with global seabird declines. However, in 2022 gannets experienced a severe outbreak of High Pathogenicity Avian Influenza (HPAI) across their global distribution, leading to an urgent need to reassess their population status. This study presents breeding gannet census numbers for 2023/24 from all colonies across the North-East Atlantic metapopulation (Great Britain, Ireland, the Channel Islands, Iceland, Norway, the Faroe Islands, France, Germany, Russia). Gannet numbers decreased by 17% across the North-East Atlantic metapopulation between the 2013/14 and 2023/24 census from 414,598 to 345,854 apparently occupied sites (AOS), a global decrease of at least 13%. The bulk of the reduction in AOS was driven by the largest colonies (>10,000 AOS) each losing tens of thousands of AOS. These figures likely underestimate the impact of the HPAI outbreak worldwide, since most colonies will have increased between the last census in 2013/14 and the 2022 HPAI outbreak, and the Canadian breeding population was last counted pre-HPAI outbreak. Scotland still holds the largest proportion of both the North-East Atlantic metapopulation (59%), and the world population (46%), while Great Britain, Ireland and the Channel Islands together hold 83% of the North-East Atlantic metapopulation and 64% of the world population. This study not only presents an updated population census for gannets in the North-East Atlantic but illustrates the large-scale impacts of a disease outbreak on a seabird species across its global range and highlights the importance of more regular census efforts to better quantify the demographic consequences of such events.

The effect of predator behaviours on the evolution of colour pattern has been extensively studied in chemically defended prey but much less so in evasive prey, although similar selection regimes might be at play. Most previous work on the recognition and learning of colour patterns by predators has relied on experiments with few model predator species, preventing a proper assessment of how natural predator communities shape the evolution of prey signals. Here, we investigate predation on evasive iridescent blue Morpho helenor butterflies by wild avian communities in a tropical forest, using artificial butterflies exposed to natural bird assemblages attracted to insect-light traps in the field. We presented five prey types: evasive (local and exotic Morpho), cryptic, palatable-control and unpalatable-control. We recorded attacks from 43 different bird species, and compared attack latency, attack order and predation exerted by different birds on different prey types. Most birds avoided evasive and defended prey, but attack responses differed depending on their levels of specialization towards insect prey. Avoidance of conspicuous coloured prey was more prevalent in specialist flight-feeding, invertivorous birds, whereas more opportunistic treehunter and frugivorous guilds had weaker discrimination. Exotic and local evasive iridescent blue Morphos experienced similar predation rates, suggesting a generalization of iridescent blue signals associated with evasiveness by most birds. Finally, contrasting selection on ventral vs. dorsal patterns was detected in M. helenor, where cryptic ventral surfaces were exposed to attack by ground-foraging birds, whereas conspicuous iridescent blue coloration displayed during flight is associated with reduced attack rates. By revealing potential differences in the responses of specialist and generalist predators, this study highlights the importance of accounting for diversity of predator traits and behaviours when investigating the evolution of aposematism, mimicry, and other anti-predator adaptations.

Birds and mammals are shrinking and shapeshifting as global temperatures rise. Ecogeographic rules predict that such changes should ease heat stress by increasing surface-area-to-volume ratios, and thus, the capacity for heat exchange. This has led to the hypothesis that body size reductions are driven by thermoregulatory selection or adaptive plasticity, although recent syntheses point to more complex, multifactorial causes. Crucially, recent theoretical models predict that thermoregulatory benefits of smaller body size only emerge at extreme deviations from average phenotypes. Here, we exploit agricultural selection in Japanese quail to directly test this hypothesis, using three breeds spanning extreme differences in body mass, surface area, and relative appendage lengths. Evaporative cooling capacity and the scope for evaporative water loss broadly followed allometric predictions when contrasting small and larger breeds. As expected, this allowed the smallest breed to tolerate higher air temperatures. However, differences in heat tolerance limits between breeds were consistently much smaller than predicted. Additionally, the breadth of thermoneutral zones overlapped in full, and upper critical temperatures were remarkably similar, between breeds. Together, these results show that heat tolerance is only weakly linked to surface-area-to-volume relationships and cannot be explained by size alone. Thus, although smaller bodies may modestly enhance heat dissipation when size variation in a population is substantial, our findings suggest that recent body size reductions and morphological shifts are unlikely to be driven primarily by thermoregulatory benefits.

Resilience is a central concept in ecology and environmental policy, yet its meaning and quantification remain inconsistent across subfields. Clarifying how resilience is defined and measured across the subfields of ecology is therefore a critical step towards delivering coordinated efforts to strengthen resilience research. Here, we analyse 594 studies published between 1977 and 2025 to determine how resilience is quantified across ecological contexts. Using large language models to extract structured data and conditional inference forests to assess predictors of metric choice, we show that resilience is most commonly ([~]25%) quantified using recovery rate and recovery degree, but no single metric dominates. Crucially, study attributes like organisational level, methodological approach, and disturbance regime explain only a small fraction of variation in metric selection. Despite this apparent inconsistency, more than 90% of studies draw from a shared set of six quantitative dimensions of resilience. This combination of weak constraint and latent convergence suggests that resilience metrics function as a flexible but implicitly standardised toolkit rather than as context-specific constructs. We argue that this hidden structure provides a foundation for a unified, multidimensional resilience framework that can support synthesis across ecological systems and improve the translation of resilience science into conservation and policy.